- If you want to lose weight and be more healthy, going on a diet may not be the best strategy.
- Making some gradual changes in what you eat could yield better long-term results.
- If you need structure to succeed, a dietitian or a eating program could be beneficial to get you started.
Whether you made a New Year’s resolution or not, you’ve likely thought about being healthier in 2023.
That probably means going on a diet, right? Not necessarily.
If you are looking for a temporary program to lose weight, a diet might be the answer. But many experts instead suggest an attitude adjustment when it comes to eating – because that strategy is a move that can lead to a longer healthier life.
By improving what you eat, you can lose weight and also avoid the yo-yo effect of weight loss and gain that can come with fad diets. An international study of 14 diets published in 2020 in the British medical journal BMJ found dieters had lost weight after six months, but most had regained the weight after a year.
“Unfortunately, when people reach their goal and stop the program, most regain the weight they’ve lost and then some,” said Mimi Secor, a nurse practitioner who specializes in women’s health and author of “Healthy & Fit at Any Age.”
New Year’s resolutions:Reviewed.com’s recommended products to help you keep your resolutions
Are you trying Dry January?:Here’s how to keep healthy clothes going all year
I want to lose weight and eat healthier. What diet should I choose?
For starters, don’t think about it as a diet. “I coach my clients to replace the word ‘diet,’ which is often viewed as a temporary solution, with the term ‘healthy eating plan’ because it is more sustainable,” said Elana Paddock, a registered dietitian nutritionist at the Cooper Clinic in Dallas, Texas.
A current popular diet is intermittent fasting, which most commonly involves eating only during 6-8 hours of the day. But a recent study in the Journal of the American Heart Association found no link between the timing of meals and weight loss over a six-year period.
However, fewer and smaller meals were associated with weight loss.
“In addition, skipping meals could lead to more hunger and cravings later, driving overeating and making it harder to make healthier food choices,” Paddock said. “In general, restrictive types of dietary approaches can lead to similar negative consequences.”
When you look at US News and World Report’s 2023 Best Diets, the top recommendations are “technically not diets the way we think of diets as something restrictive,” Gretel Schueller, managing editor of health at US News, told USA TODAY. “They’re a lifestyle approach.”
What are some good diets to consider as better eating plans?
The Mediterranean diet, which emphasizes vegetables, fruits, lean poultry, seafood, whole grains, nuts and unsaturated fat from extra-virgin olive oil, is “really more of an eating style and it’s really adaptable,” Schueller said.
“The diets that do well don’t restrict entire food groups or make you feel like you’re missing something. A better way to think of them is as an eating pattern,” Schueller said.
Mediterranean diet:Named ‘best diet overall’ for 6th year in a row. Here’s how to start it.
Trying the Mediterranean diet?:Start with these great recipes for breakfast, lunch and dinner
Two other top diets recommended in US News and World Report’s list are the DASH diet – it stands for dietary approaches to stop hypertension – limits foods high in saturated fat, as well as sweetened beverages, and the Flexitarian diet, a semi-vegetarian diet focusing on non-meat proteins such as beans, peas or eggs – plus fruits and vegetables – as a way to reduce meat intake.
Other than sodium restrictions for the DASH diet, these are “not restrictive and are really about focusing on the things we know we should eat: whole foods, vegetables, fruit, whole grains and so on, and limiting our candy and processed foods,” Schueller said.
What are some important factors to consider in choosing a diet or eating plan?
If a diet or eating plan is too restrictive, you are less likely to stick with it. Other important questions to ask before embarking on a new eating strategy include:
- Are any favorite foods not allowed?
- Are all food groups included? What does our monetary budget allow?
- What about other family members?
“If you’re cooking for a whole family, but one person is eating different than the rest of everyone at the table, that’s not very sustainable,” Schueller said. “The more complicated the diet becomes, the less likely it is you’re going to stick to it long term.”
Those diets ranking high on US News and World Report’s list can serve as the basis for a long-term healthy eating plan. Each suggests the limiting of unhealthy foods and stresses portion control.
“Whatever you choose, it has got to consist of healthy foods and drinks – and allows you the occasional treat. That way you can stick to it,” Schueller said.
Carnivore and lion diets:Is eating only meat really good for you?
What’s everyone talking about?:Sign up for our trending newsletter to get the latest news of the day
I don’t want to go on a diet, but I want to make some simple changes.
Start with small changes. Drink more water – ideally eight 8-ounce glasses daily – and start recording your food intake with an app such as MyFitnessPal, Secor suggests.
“Or maybe start going to bed 15 minutes earlier or start walking around the block every day,” she said. “Don’t try to change everything at once. You will just get overwhelmed and are more likely to throw in the towel until next year.”
Pick one or two specific changes to focus on and go from there, Paddock said. Some suggestions:
- Swap out white bread or white rice with whole wheat bread or brown rice (these have more nutrients).
- Choose light popcorn instead of potato chips.
- Buy individual portions of nuts or snacks instead of large containers – or fill small snack bags for portion control.
- Have fruit handy instead of always opting for sweets or salty snacks.
- Use smaller plates and bowls so portions are smaller.
- Eat leaner protein such as chicken or fish – or beans – when you might have had red meat.
- After dinner, consider the kitchen closed until morning.
“You can consider a small steps approach with healthier swaps and build one success on another which not only leads to positive changes, but is also motivating,” Paddock said.
Rethinking obesity:What we eat matters. Researchers are still searching for the ‘best’ diet.
weight gain:Obesity was long considered a personal failing. Science shows it’s not.
What if I need a more stringent regimen?
- Seek out a registered dietician. These nutrition specialists “can be a valuable tool to tailor a plan with you and navigate the choices that fit your needs and lifestyle,” Paddock said. You can find a nutrition expert on the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics website.
- Try a program. If you aren’t an experienced cook, perhaps try a program such as Weight Watchers, Nutrisystem or Optavia, which has foods you can purchase and guidelines to help with portions. “Some of these more structured commercial diets might work for (the person), even if it is just for a limited time to sort of jumpstart a healthy eating pattern,” Schueller said.
- Get a physical trainer. Food is only part of a healthy lifestyle; physical activity is another. But exercise is part of the “holistic approach … of the healthy lifestyle that you’re picking,” Schueller said.
Follow Mike Snider on Twitter: @mikesnider.